Site Map | Search Warsailors.com |Merchant Fleet Main Page | Warsailors.com Home 

M/S Jamaica

To Jamaica on the "Ships starting with J" page.

Survivors & Casualties

Owner: Skibs-A/S Rose
Manager: Anders Jahre, Sandefjord
Tonnage:
3015 gt, 1756 net.
Call Sign: LTGE

Built in Copenhagen 1936. Previous name: Giuba until 1938.

Captain: Arnfinn Bergan.

Other pages on this website with info related to Jamaica:
Convoy HX 140
A message in my Guestbook from Dr. Axel Niestlé. This is very interesting because it indicates, based on U 221's war diary, that one of Jamaica's crew members was kept aboard the U-boat for several days, until he jumped overboard on March 21. I have not seen this mentioned elsewhere. Norwegian sources say the Norwegian 3rd engineer was taken aboard the boat and questioned, but was allowed back in the lifeboat again after about 10-15 minutes. If anyone has information that can throw some light on this, please contact me at the address at the bottom of this page.
A guestbook message from the grandson of one of the survivors, Olaf Olsen, who lives in Liverpool.

Jamaica was damaged by mine off Mackenzie Buoy on Oct. 29-1940, but managed to get to Avonmouth the next day.

There's a ship by this name listed as sailing in Convoy HX 140 in July-1941, but I'm not entirely sure if this was the Norwegian one.

 Jamaica's Final Fate: 

Torpedoed in the starboard side by U-221 (Trojer) in the morning of March 7-1943 and sunk in approx. 52N 27W, when on a voyage alone from Liverpool to New York in ballast, having departed on March 4. The torpedo was believed to have detonated in the refrigerated hold amidships, because an intense smell of ammonia was noted after the explosion. She broke in two and sank in 2 minutes. 4 lifeboats were launched, though 2 were damaged and could not be used. As the ship sank the motor lifeboat was sucked down and came up capsized, but was righted and bailed.

* The position given above is from my Norwegian sources. Rohwer gives the position as 48N 23 30W.

 Summary of statements given at the Maritime Hearings: 
The hearings were held in London on May 24 with the 2nd engineer, the 3rd engineer, Able Seaman B. Larsen, Able Seaman Henriksen, and Mechanic Hauge appearing.

Able seaman Bjarne Larsen explained that he had been in the messroom aft when the torpedo hit and went straight to the boat deck where he and Mechanic Fosseli, Able Seaman Dale and Mechanic Strandskog launched the motorboat from the port side. Dale remained on the boat deck, while the others in the boat were sucked under when the ship sank. One of the British Radio Operators had also attempted to get in this boat, but did not succeed (1st Radio Operator Ewart Francis Wilkinson). Larsen says he had heard the 2 cooks crying for help in the galley, and since both doors were open, he assumed they had been injured and therefore unable to get themselves out. When Larsen came to the surface again he saw the capsized motorboat nearby, then swam towards it and was able to climb onto it.

Mechanic Hauge, who was in his aft cabin at the time of the explosion, entered the starboard lifeboat, but after the U-boat had "rammed it on purpose" (see *) he jumped overboard and swam towards the capsized motorboat. He states that the U-boat also attempted to ram this boat which had several people on it, but fortunately a large wave came just then and the motorboat was swung away at the last moment and was not hit by the U-boat.

2nd Engineer Karl Engebreth Møller says he was in his cabin amidships when the torpedo hit, but the explosion threw him up on deck. No alarm had been sounded beforehand, leading him to believe that those on duty on deck had not seen the U-boat before the torpedo hit. He went to the starboard lifeboat which was launched with the help of the other 4 men present, then rowed away from Jamaica to keep from being sucked under. He had noticed that most of the crew had gone to the port side of Jamaica and in his opinion this was to avoid the gas eminating from the refrigerated hold.

He says that after the ship had gone down, the U-boat came up and asked for the captain and chief engineer. After having been told that they had probably gone down with the ship, because they had not been seen, the U-boat ran straight into the side of the lifeboat, on purpose (*), and damaged it even further, so that it became useless, but they succeeded in rowing it over to "half a raft" and tied the boat to it. The gig came over towing the motorboat, which was put alongside the raft and bailed, whereupon all the supplies in the starboard boat were transferred to the motorboat. The gig then rowed over to the wreckage of the port lifeboat in which there were 2 men and a search was undertaken for possible survivors in the water but none were to be seen. All supplies from the port boat was transferred to the gig, which now had 4 people. 13 were in the motorboat.

The 4 in the gig did not want to stay with the other boat, so proceeded in a southerly direction. In the gig at that time were Steward Jens A. Menzoni, Able Seaman Eilef Daniel Henriksen, Gunner Thorbjørn Olsen, and Olaf Eliassen. The others readied the motorboat, then sailed in the same direction as the gig, leaving the raft and starboard boat behind. (Due to it having been damaged it was impossible to use the motor, therefore, sail had to be used). There were 2 compasses in the boat and course was set for southeast, later east. The 2 fresh water tanks in the boat were leaking and the contents were mixed with seawater, but they used the water from 4 water kegs, presumably taken from the damaged boat.

One of the able seamen, Einar Larsen, who had been at the helm when the torpedo hit had a badly injured thigh. He was covered up and taken care of as best they could. Before noon on the 9th they were spotted by a Flying Fortress aircraft, which circled around the boat a few times and threw down a box containing First Aid articles, as well as misc. other items that they were unable to pick up. After a while their feet swelled up in spite of massaging them and many were in a lot of pain.

In the morning of the 18th at around 7:30 in the morning they were picked by the corvette HMS Borage (K-120). There was no doctor on board, but they were treated by the ship's deacon and given the best of care. Borage then altered course to meet up with another corvette which had a doctor on board, and 3 of Jamaica's men whose injuries were the most severe were transferred there, to be taken to Gibraltar as quickly as possible. Borage, meanwhile, met up with, and joined a convoy en route to England, and the remaining survivors arrived Plymouth on March 26, then continued to London the next day.

A gunner also reported that the U-boat purposely rammed the lifeboat. He says that most of its occupants were able to cling to the resulting debris, but 3rd Engineer Odd A. Ernstsen had fallen overboard and was picked up by the U-boat, where his lifevest was "emptied" before he was "thrown back into the sea again"**. The gunner adds that the U-boat then ran around among the people swimming in the water, and it gradually grew quiet, so that they were convinced that some of them had been killed. All the witnesses say they heard the cries and whistles from survivors swimming in the water nearby (they could not be seen, only heard, due to the tall seas), but after the U-boat had gone in that direction it all went quiet.

* I don't know whether Trojer was the kind of man capable of such behaviour, but naturally, this report was utilized in British propaganda as proof of the fact that German U-boats practised a kind of warfare that must be termed criminal. (One of the witnesses at the hearings had heard that it was common practice of the U-boats to cruise around among survivors in the water, killing them with the propellers. There were probably all kinds of rumours going around about U-boats in those days, putting fear and hatred into the seamen). The most likely explanation is probably that the U-boat had difficulties maneuvering inbetween the debris, boats and swimming people. One witness, Able Seaman Henriksen admits when questioned that it was possible that their shipmates had simply drifted further away after a while and therefore could not be heard anymore. Additionally, some of them did not have their lifevests on. Also, in Odd Ernstsen's own statement the term "thrown into the sea" was altered to "the U-boat's captain said he could jump into the sea again", which he did, then swam over to the starboard lifeboat. He further stated that he was never inside the U-boat, only in the conning tower. He had seen nothing that could identify the boat, but had heard from others that there was a black cat painted on it.

** Please go to the Guestbook message that I've linked to further up on this page for some new details on this.

The gunner's report further states that Gunner Thorbjørn O. Olsen, Gunner Larsen and Gunner Eliassen were in the aft messroom when the torpedo hit, while Gunner Gunnar Hellerud was on lookout duty on the bridge. Gunner Olaf Olsen was in bed and Gunner Anton Johansen was also in his cabin. Th. O. Olsen jumped into the sea and was able to get into a damaged lifeboat, while Larsen, O. Olsen and Eliassen launched the gig and managed to get into it.

At the time the other 13 survivors were landed in Plymouth, the 4 men who had left the scene of the torpedoing in Jamaica's gig were still missing, but on March 29 word came that they had reached Isle of Barra where they received medical treatment before being sent to London Apr. 6.

A total of 21 had died, including Captain Bergan. 1st Mate Samson Myrdal was believed to have been in the motor boat which initially went down with the suction when Jamaica sank, while 3rd Mate Charles Berg was on duty on the bridge when the torpedo hit. The latter had been seen floating in the water with half his face gone. Those who had been on duty in the engine room, namely 4th Engineer (assistant) Arne Nilsen, Mechanic Erik Gulbrandsen and Electrician Thorleif Sedolfsen were assumed killed instantly during the explosion. 1st Engineer Rolf Larsen had not been feeling well that morning and had probably gone to bed before the accident happened. Gunner Thor Hauff Thorsen, who had been on gun duty, had placed himself on the raft on No. 3 hatch, but the raft got jammed under the beams and Thorsen died.

Crew List:

Survivors
Able Seaman
Einar Larsen
Able Seaman
Bjarne Johan Larsen
Able Seaman
Eilef Daniel Henriksen
Able Seaman
Olaf Eliassen
Able Seaman/Gunner
Olaf Olsen
Able Seaman/Gunner
Chler Øarsem *
Able Seaman/Gunner
Thorbjørn Olsen
2nd engineer
Karl E. Møller
3rd Engineer
Odd A. Ernstsen
Refrigerator Engineer
Henry Mikalsen
Mechanic
Arne Østheim Fosseli
Mechanic
Olav Olsen
Mechanic
Johan Hauge
Mechanic
Øivind Nilsen
Steward
Jens A. Menzoni
Saloon Boy
William D. Roberts
(British)
Saloon Boy
Allan Ratcliffe
(British)

* I find this a very strange name and wonder if it's misspelt.

Casualties

Captain
Arnfinn Bergan

1st Mate
Samson Myrdal

2nd Mate
Harald Bærulfsen

3rd Mate
Charles Berg

Radio Operator
Ewart Francis Wilkinson*
(British)

Radio Operator
Alfred Riley*
(British)

Radio Operator
Erling Sivertsen

Boatswain
Aksel Andersen

Able Seaman
Thorvald Dale

Able Seaman/Gunner
Thor Hauff Thorsen

Able Seaman/Gunner
Anton Johansen

Able Seaman/Gunner
Gunnar Hellerud

1st Engineer
Rolf Larsen

Assistant
Arne Nilsen

Electrician
Thorleif Sedolfsen

Mechanic
Ingvald Storebø

Mechanic
Harald Strandskog

Mechanic
Erik Gulbrandsen

Oiler
Rolf Rynning

Cook
Christian Solberg

2nd Cook
Karsten Jensen

* The British casualties can be found by entering their names in the relevant search field on The Commonwealth War Graves Comm. website (external link) - here is A. Riley and here is E. W. Wilkinson - date of death is given as March 7-1943 for both.

I've found some information in an article of Issue No. 4 for 1982 of the Norwegian magazine "Krigsseileren" with regard to the 16 year old British Alan Ratcliffe from Liverpool who survived the attack on Jamaica. He was among the 13 in the lifeboat, as was the 19 year old Mechanic Arne Fosseli. During a stay in Liverpool in 1977 Arne Fosseli came across some old newspapers containing Alan Ratcliffe's story and through a subsequent notice in a Liverpool newspaper he was able to find him and the 2 were reunited. They were in the cabin of another English boy when the torpedo hit, causing the door to jam but they were able to get out through the porthole. Alan was in the lifeboat that was rammed by the U-boat and was caught on the boat for a while before being thrown off, and was subsequently picked up by a lifeboat, but his legs had been severely injured during the ordeal. During the 11 days in the lifeboat his legs got progressively worse and gangrene set in. He was among the ones who were transferred from Borage to another corvette and taken to a military hospital in Gibraltar where his legs had to be amputated. He was later sent to England where he got artificial legs. (There's a picture of him at the hospital, and another one of him and Arne Fosseli at their reunion. A. Fosseli died in 1996).

Related external links:
Those who died
- 20 Norwegians are commemorated at this Memorial for Seamen in Stavern, Norway. When adding the 2 British seamen named above the total comes to 22 instead of the 21 reported elsewhere. One explanation might be that one of the seamen commemorated at this memorial might have died at another time. In fact, there are 2 names here that are not on my list above, namely Arne Sigvald Johansen and Erling Johan Lammenes - the latter is listed as radio operator, and he is, in fact, idententical to Erling Sivertsen in my crew list).

Operations Information for U-221 - As can be seen, this U-boat was responsible for the sinking of several other Norwegian ships.

U-221 | Hans-Hartwig Trojer

B-17 (Flying Fortress) - from Skylighters.

To Jamaica on the "Ships starting with J" page.

Norway had also lost a ship by this name during WW I - built 1909 for Adolph Halvorsen, later managed by Westfal-Larsen, Bergen. Lost off Oporto on Jan. 1-1915, 15 died, 1 survived.

The text on this page was compiled with the help of: "Nortraships flåte", J. R. Hegland, "Sjøforklaringer fra 2. verdenskrig", Norwegian Maritime Museum, Volume I, "Krigsseileren" Issue No. 4 for 1982, and misc. others for cross checking info, incl. "Axis Submarine Successes of World War II", Jürgen Rohwer and "The World's Merchant Fleets", Roger W. Jordan.

   Be   
C
   D   
E
F
G
   He   
I
J
   K   
L
M
N
O
   PQ   
R
   So   
   To   
U
V
W
   Ø   

 Site Map | Search Warsailors.com |Merchant Fleet Main Page | Warsailors.com Home